>> ASIAONE / MOTORING / NEWS / STORY
How $60 dispute ended up costing $100,000
Wed, Oct 03, 2007
AsiaOne

ACCIDENT:
Mr Lock's motorbike and Ms Goh's car collide in Nov 2004.
Mr Lock files lawsuit against Ms Goh in Sep 2005.

1st RULING
PDRC district judge orders both sides to bear 50% liability ($187.50 each) in Mar 2006
Ms Goh's insurers, NTUC Income, to pay costs of $1,000, plus lawyers' expenses.

DISPUTE OVER COSTS
Lawyers can't agree if Mr Lock's former lawyer Andrew Hanam's expenses is $230 or $290. Mr Hanam takes out writ of seizure and sale against Ms Goh for costs.
Ms Goh's insurer, NTUC Income, pays sum ordered by court and costs.

APPEAL
Between May and Nov, NTUC Income's lawyer, Mr Assomull, attempts to get seizure and March consent order to be set aside.
Appeal is rejected by deputy registrar, District Court.
In Feb 2007, NTUC Income is allowed to take case to High Court.

1st RULING OVERTURNED
On 26 Apri, Justice Lai Siu Chiu rules that PDRC is not a court, March consent order set aside.
Mr Lock must now pay legal costs of $63,000. Sum later revised to $45,000. He fires Mr Hanam, who bills him $80,000.
Last month, NTUC Income serves write of seizure on Mr Lock but later offers to waive $45,000 legal bill and give $25,000 as goodwill money.

FINAL APPEAL
Mr Lock turns down offer and proceeds to win appeal in Court of Appeal yesterday.

 

 
STORY INDEX
 
  How $60 dispute ended up costing $100,000
   
 
  Leaner German automaker Daimler seeks fresh start
   
 
  Teacher Jonathan Lock wins appeal
   
 
  Ralf?s exit makes no difference, says Toyota
   
 
  Hamilton title would be tainted, says Montezemolo
   
 
  Alonso?s options for next season narrow
   
 
  US auto sales slump amid slowdown
   
 
  Blind people say noiseless hybrid cars pose safety risk
   
 
  1 in 6 Irish drivers has never passed driving test
   
 
  Sarkozy fingered for speeding
   
>> RELATED STORY
How $60 dispute ended up costing $100,000
Teacher Jonathan Lock wins appeal
If only he didn't switch lawyers...
Teacher could have avoided hefty legal bill
We welcome contributions, comments and tips.
a1motor@sph.com.sg
Search: